Mortgage Principal Reductions Back in Focus (Update 1)
NEW YORK (TheStreet) -- President Obama is expected to nominate a new director for the Federal Housing Finance Agency on Wednesday, a move that consumer advocates hope will pave the way for greater mortgage relief to borrowers.
Rep. Mel Watt (D-N.C) -- a member of the House Financial Services Committee -- has been picked to run the regulator of government-sponsored enterprises Fannie Mae
Watt has previously pushed for changes in mortgage lending practices and for improving access to credit for low income and minority borrowers.
Significantly, Watt has been supportive of principal reductions, a contentious form of mortgage relief that has been stiffly opposed by the FHFA's current acting director Edward DeMarco.
The appointment, if confirmed, could pave the way for principal reductions by the GSEs, though it is likely to be contested by Senate Republicans.
Advocates of principal reduction believe it is the most effective form of mortgage relief for deeply underwater borrowers, as it not only lowers the monthly payment but also restores more equity in the home and reduces the likelihood that the borrower will walk away from their mortgage.
A study by Amherst Securities analyst Laurie Goodman last year showed that principal reductions result in the lowest default rate among mortgage assistance options. For 2011 modifications, for example, the re-default rate after 12 months for principal modifications was 12 percent, compared to 23 percent for rate modifications and 30 percent for capitalization modifications, according to the report.
The FHFA's DeMarco, however, has resisted pressure from the Administration to reduce principal on mortgages, arguing that the program would be too costly for taxpayers, complicated to administer and would encourage strategic defaults by borrowers hoping to take advantage of the program.
Since the GSEs account for nearly 60% of the country's mortgages, relatively few borrowers have been able to benefit from this form of relief.
Liberal activists who have been calling for DeMarco to be replaced on Wednesday applauded the decision to appoint Watt.
The appointment is a "victory for American homeowners, taxpayers, and our economic recovery," according to Alan Jenkins, Executive Director of The Opportunity Agenda. "We congratulate President Obama on this important move, and call on the U.S. Senate to quickly consider Congressman Watt's nomination. Swiftly replacing DeMarco with a Home Opportunity Hero like Mel Watt will uphold our national values of opportunity and fairness while speeding our economic recovery."