Chance of Jos A. Bank Acquisition Is 1%, Analyst Says (Update 1)
This story has been updated from 1:24 p.m. with quotes from the CEO.
NEW YORK (TheStreet) - The possibility of Jos A. Bank Clothiers
The menswear retailer announced late Friday that it is considering "strategic opportunities to enhance shareholder value," which include potential acquisitions. It hired investment banking firm Financo, according to a press release.
The Hampstead, Md.-based Jos A. Bank said Friday it was looking at various "opportunities," including selective, long-term accretive acquisitions. The company intends to retain capital not needed for operations, it said. It did not give a timetable for any acquisition.
But Mark Montagna, an equity analyst at Avondale Partners, questions the real motive for the release. He says the likelihood of an acquisition for Jos A. Bank is minimal. Montagna rates the company market underperform.
"Nobody on senior management has any experience with acquisitions," Montagna wrote in an email to TheStreet on Monday. "They also have no experience with wholesaling, which essentially eliminates acquisitions such as the rumor of their looking at Lucky
Montagna says the real motivation for Friday's press release was to justify former CEO and non-executive chairman Robert N. Wildrick's annual $825,000 consulting fee. Wildrick, 68, was the company's chief executive for nine years before stepping aside in 2008 to become non-executive chairman.
"This fee relates to his providing strategic advice, including surfacing possible acquisitions. Prior to this release, there had been no company commentary regarding acquisitions, yet this contract has been in place for multiple years and continues through Jan. 30, 2016," says Montagna, citing a regulatory filing.
"We'd like to find opportunities where we can leverage the management expertise that we have and the assets of the company where the combined expertise represents long-term value for our shareholders," CEO R. Neal Black said in an interview with TheStreet. "It could be lots of different things depending upon the circumstances."
Black declined to comment on any specific deals being worked on or the possibility of a merger with Men's Wearhouse.
When asked directly about Montagna's assertions, Black responded: "Strategic initiatives, which include acquisitions, are a continuing subject for our board and management and have been for some time."
In a 2011 article from The Baltimore Sun, which questioned Wildrick's pricey compensation, Wildrick said the fee was justified because of the amount of time he spends on consulting duties. The contract also doesn't allow him to work for another retail company.
He also said in the article that he didn't plan to stay in the consulting role beyond 2014.
In addition, the release came after shareholders at the company's contentious annual meeting on Friday rejected compensation packages for CEO R. Neal Black and other top executives and criticized Black for not using the company's cash to do a stock buyback, The Baltimore Sun reported.