United Should Close Dulles Hub, Analyst Says, as He Cuts Rating
CHICAGO (TheStreet) -- A veteran airline analyst downgraded shares of United
In a scathing report issued Thursday, Imperial Capital analyst Bob McAdoo reduced his rating for United to "in-line" from "outperform," and cut his one-year price target to $47 from $55. At the close Thursday, United shares were at $41.51, down 30 cents for the day, but still up 9.7% year to date.
"From a trading perspective, shares of UAL may continue to move upward as sector sentiment remains positive," McAdoo wrote. However, he said, "United's presentations and published plans (indicate it) will take at least four years to close $2 billion of the gap on American
"Importantly, during those four years, Delta and American will be similarly working to increase earnings," he wrote. Year-to-date, United shares are up 10%, while Delta shares are up 43% and American shares are up 76%.
McAdoo panned the presentation United executives made at a November investor day event, where they outlined a $2 billion program of cost and revenue improvements.
It "seemed more likely to be found in a typical operating department's annual budget presentation than in a corporate presentation as to how United's results would be lifted to record levels," he wrote, noting that adjustments such as reducing overtime "will not close the gap with Delta and American."
What United should do, McAdoo argued, is to close the Dulles hub, given its proximity to the hub in Newark, N.J. Other airlines have realized synergies by closing hubs that are close together, he said, and United has already moved to close its redundant Cleveland hub.
Moreover, local passengers to Washington generally prefer to fly to US Airways' hub at Reagan National. McAdoo estimated that at best, Dulles flights can get only 20% to 30% of local traffic to Washington.
"United would not operate two payroll departments, so we wonder why it would operate two hubs only 211 miles apart?" McAdoo asked. "Both hubs connect traffic from the eastern third of the country to Europe (and) connect north/south domestic traffic. By eliminating the smaller of the two hubs, United would see outsized savings and improved profitability across the entire United route network."
The Washington hub was created to compete with Continental's Newark hub. The two airlines merged in 2010, yet "almost four years after the merger, it is still competing," McAdoo said. "Today the Dulles hub is the smallest in the northeast, carrying fewer passengers to Europe than Newark, than Delta at JFK or American Airlines/US Airways in Philadelphia." In fact, Newark, with 32 daily departures to Europe, is the largest and strongest of the four.
Yet curiously, United flies Boeing
"United's cuts in Cleveland set the standard for whether to unwind the Washington Dulles hub," McAdoo noted. In Cleveland, he said, 17 markets with less than 10 local passengers per flight and 16 markets with generally 11 to 30 local passengers per flight were eliminated as of next month. Using the same metrics in Dulles, 65 spoke routes would be cut.