Why the U.S. Stinks at Mobile Payments: Street Whispers
NEW YORK (TheStreet) -Consumer Financial Protection Bureau director Richard Cordray presumably wore a straight face during a speech Wednesday in Mountain View, Calif., subtitled "Stimulating Innovation in Financial Products and Services," though it is easy to be skeptical.
Few in the U.S. look to a regulator for innovation, though to Cordray's credit, his speech contained at least a few specifics--real companies with which the CFPB is collaborating. These include BillGuard, a company that alerts consumers to questionable charges on their debit and credit cards, which will share its billing dispute data with the bureau , and Simple and Plastyc--mobile banking companies that aim to replace traditional banks.
Details about these collaborations are still scarce, however, and Robert Atkinson, president of the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation (ITIF), has his doubts about whether the new regulator will embrace innovation.
One area where Atkinson would like to see the U.S. make progress is with mobile payments. There has been lots of hype surrounding a well-financed start-up called Square and its recently announced partnership with Starbucks(SBUX) , as well as efforts by Bank of America(BAC) Citigroup(C) and JPMorgan Chase(JPM) , among others, to offer mobile payments technology to their customers. Still, the U.S. is well behind Japan and South Korea in embracing this technology, and a 2009 paper by ITIF senior analyst Stephen Ezell lays out some of the issues that need to be addressed to catch up.
"Countries can't just snap their fingers and put a mobile payments infrastructure in place or expect that because the technology is now ready the private sector will simply deploy it," Ezell writes. "Mobile payments entail a complex, system-interdependent ecosystem with many players--including mobile network operators (MNOs), handset manufacturers, financial institutions including major banks and credit card issuers, merchants, public transit authorities, government agencies, third party application providers, and consumers--whose success is dependent on joint action by all the players together at the same time. Everyone must act collaboratively in the ecosystem simultaneously, but this is not something at which markets tend to be very good."