EU Charges Biggest U.S. Banks in CDS Market Antitrust Suit
NEW YORK ( TheStreet) -- Thirteen of world's largest investment banks, International Swaps and Derivatives Association and data provider Markit Group have been charged by the European Commission of blocking entrants into the opaque but lucrative credit default swap market, in violation of antitrust law.
On Monday, the European Commission said the syndicate of banks, ISDA and Markit had used their market position to shut German exchange Deutsche Boerse and U.S. commodities exchange the Chicago Mercantile Exchange
The European Commission has charged Goldman Sachs
ISDA is the trade group that represents Wall Street derivatives traders and it also is tasked with coordinating changes to the market. Markit is a financial data provider that owns licenses to the most highly traded CDS index contracts.
"It would be unacceptable if banks collectively blocked exchanges to protect their revenues from over-the-counter trading of credit derivatives," EU Competition Commissioner Joaquin Almunia said in a Monday statement. Banks fines of up to 10% of their revenue if found guilty of breaking EU antitrust rules.
CDS trading, while risky, is a highly profitable business for large banks because Wall Street dealers are able to set the price of many contracts in bilateral negotiations done off of an exchange. Exchange-traded products such as stocks and futures, by contrast, have generally seen trading commissions and fees drop precipitously as markets have embraced electronic trading.
In the wake of the financial crisis, many exchanges have sought to enter the CDS market with electronic trading platforms. Some exchanges such as IntercontinentalExchange
New players such as Bloomberg have applied to become so-called swap-execution facilities, as an increasing number of products face clearing and electronic trading mandates. Meanwhile, Intercontinental Exchange has a licensing agreement with Markit to create CDS futures contracts.
In recent years, Deutsche Boerse, the Chicago Board of Options Exchange and the CME have all tried to build CDS futures contracts, however, success was limited by a lack of participation from large banks and an inability to get key licenses.
Deutsche Boerse and CME Group, for instance, weren't able to obtain licenses to Markit's index products as they tried to build electronically traded CDS futures contracts, the European Commission said.
The European Commission's antitrust probe was opened in April 2011 and focused on whether Markit, owned by the largest derivatives traders, had tried to curb new entrants in the market.