'Virtual Value' Isn't Good Enough for This Stock
That shares are currently trading at $76.80 (as of this writing) means the stock is down 22% from a high of $99.10 reached just ahead of the report. But was it justified? Although valuation had been a popular cited bear argument, VMware has proven that it can meet growth expectations. This quarter was no different, at least not entirely.
For the period ending in December, VMware earned 81 cents per share on revenue of $1.29 billion, beating EPS estimates of 78 cents and edging out the consensus revenue projection by $1 billion.As VMware has often shown, growth has never been a problem as evident by the 22% climb. Likewise, net income advanced 3% to $205.8 million, or 47 cents per share.
VMware also showed it was doing well with recurring revenue as licenses grew 16% year-over-year. Even though this was 3% slower than Red Hat (RHT) , it arrived in line with estimates. On the other hand, maintenance/service revenue surged 27% - outperforming Citrix's (CTXS) 22%. Clearly, VMware is holding its own from a competitive standpoint.
Profitability was also impressive. Not only did gross margins advance 60 basis points year over year, but it beat Street estimates by one point. What's more, operating income grew 25% year over year and 16% from the previous quarter.So with a report like this one would expect the stock to trend upward. The Street saw things differently -- with a little help from management.
End of the Run?
This is what investors are wondering today after management issued guidance that arrived below consensus. The company projected first-quarter revenue in the range of $1.17 to $1.19 billion, which was 5% lower than what analysts were modeling at $1.25 billion. On these numbers, the stock got hammered -- falling below its 50- and 200-day moving averages.
In other words, management is calling for growth of 13%, or 7% lower than what would have pleased investors. What's more, analysts absolutely hated that VMware guided license revenue for growth in only single digits versus growth estimates of 14%. Granted, these adjustments weren't entirely drastic. Then again, the premiums investors have been paying were not for average performance either.
It also didn't escape analysts that license billings posted only 7% growth, the second consecutive quarter of single-digit movement. This means that demand is beginning to slow. Although there had been concerns about the overall health of the virtualization industry, it is clear these worries are valid.