What's To Make Of Nokia's Indian Tax Appeal Loss?
Chris Lau, Kapitall: Nokia lost its tax appeal with the Indian Supreme Court. How will this affect Nokia stock?
Just as Nokia (NOK) was about to transfer its devices units to Microsoft (MSFT), the company hit a snag. Last week the Supreme Court in India upheld a lower court ruling that Nokia owes 35 billion rupees in taxes. Nokia is trading at multiple tops: its shares tried many times to break the $8 level. How should investors react to the latest setback?
Nokia loses appeal
India’s lower court previously ruled Nokia owed tax following the transfer of ownership of a Nokia factory to Microsoft. The setback is negative for Nokia shareholders, because it represents a big part of the smartphone business that must be transferred to Microsoft.
Nokia’s business transformation is already facing hiccups. The company has massive cash thanks to the sale, but its network and maps divisions need management’s focus to operate more profitably.
Nokia’s India asset stuck
India’s tax policy for foreign firms is unpredictable, so Nokia shareholders should be aware of the political uncertainty surrounding the factory sale.
The Finnish phone maker must tread carefully with India as it negotiates its tax liability. It is possible the company will need to cease investments in the factory (though it remains shut down), otherwise its potential tax burden will increase. On the other hand, by creating lost employment opportunities, India will be pressured to relax its terms.
Nokia shares dip
Nokia might even need to consider abandoning the factory, along with this portion of the sale to Microsoft. Forgoing the profit will set a precedent for Nokia’s other business objectives. Future contracts, acquisitions, and businesses done in its maps and networking divisions will include stronger contract wording minimizing such liabilities.